Alan Ritchson
Thad Castle
Darin Brooks
Alex Moran
Chris Romano
Sammy Cacciatore
Frankie Shaw
Mary Jo Cacciatore
Ed Marinaro
Coach Marty Daniels
James Cade
Harmon Tedesco
Rob Ramsay
Donnie Schrab
Omari Newton
Larry Summers
Kelly Kruger
Julia King
Sam Jones
Craig Shiloh
Page Kennedy
Radon Randell
Lindsey Sporrer
Holly
Jimmy Tatro
Dick Dawg
Dhani Jones
Dhani Jones
Remington Jay Perregaux
Satan / Gift Wrap Man
Erica Page
Tina
Ed Amatrudo
Dean Olivares
Barry Ratcliffe
Auctioneer
William Frasca
Nerdy Looking Kid
Anthony Reynolds
Cop
Hudson Shank
Young Thad
Katelynn Derengowski
Stephanie
Leann Lei
Mojito Girl
Brittany Ann Boudreault
Amber
Mary Elizabeth Runyon
Valerie
Greggory Daniels
Second Student
Miles Duffield
Third Student
Derek Severson
Football Player (uncredited)