Sara Paxton
Susan Wright
Justin Bruening
Jeff Wright
Lisa Edelstein Russell
Kelly Siegler
Michael Gross
Ron Wright
Annie Corley
Mrs. Wright
Joshua Snyder
Randy
W. Earl Brown
Thomas Dean
Lucinda Jenney
Susan's Mother
David Marciano
Detective
Matthew Del Negro
Jeff's Co-Worker
Erin Cahill
Cindy
Annie Wersching
Allie
Jon Curry
Ben Furhman
Sam McMurray
Dr. Sheffield
Vyto Ruginis
Philip Gross
Pat Skipper
Judge
Nancy Grace
Nancy Grace
Jonathan Patrick Moore
Billy
Cade Owens
Andrew
Aaron Lustig
Dr. Slovin
Zuleyka Silver
Maria
Elijah Adams
Yard Sale Buyer