Quinn Shephard
Abigail
Nadia Alexander
Melissa
Trieste Kelly Dunn
Jennifer
Marcia DeBonis
Ms. Cohen
Tessa Albertson
Ellie
Sarah Mezzanotte
Sophie
Luke Slattery
Eric
Tate Donovan
Robert
Chris Messina
Jeremy Woods
Elizabeth Howell
Abigail's Mother
Carlyle Owens
Abigail's Father
Geneva Carr
Mrs. Howell
Whitney Harris
Melissa's mother (voice)
Lily Houghton
Lily / Drama Student
Phelan Tupik
Phelan / Drama Student
Michael Jefferson
Hallway Teacher
Larry Mitchell
Officer Dolan
Julie Dwoskin
Drama Student
Sherilyn James
Drama Student
Jack Labbe
Drama Student
Ashley La Selva
Drama Student
Michelle Martinez
Drama Student