Susan Sarandon
Adele August
Natalie Portman
Ann August
Hart Bochner
Josh Spritzer
Eileen Ryan
Lillian
Ray Baker
Ted
John Diehl
Jimmy
Shawn Hatosy
Benny
Bonnie Bedelia
Carol
Faran Tahir
Hisham Badir
Shishir Kurup
Hisham Badir (voice)
Elisabeth Moss
Rachel
John Carroll Lynch
Jack Irwin
Caroline Aaron
Gail Letterfine
Paul Guilfoyle
George Franklin
Thora Birch
Mary
Mary Ellen Trainor
Homeowner
Ashley Johnson
Sarah
Corbin Allred
Peter
Eva Amurri Martino
Girl on TV
Heather DeLoach
Ellen
Stephanie Niznik
Waitress
Heather McComb
Janice Pearlman
Lindley Harrison
Janice's Mother
Michael Milhoan
Cop
Bob Sattler
Bernie
Nina Leichtling
Josh's Wife
Jay Harrington
Waiter
Andy Bowles
Mourner
Rick Hurst
Reverend
Rachel Wilson
Sylvia
Stephen Berra
Hal
Nina Barry
Casting Assistant
Cricky Long
Casting Executive
Lillian Adams
Jack's Mother
Megan Mullally
Woman Buying Car
George Peck
Man with Luggage