Annabelle Wallis
Mia Form
Ward Horton
John Form
Tony Amendola
Father Perez
Alfre Woodard
Evelyn
Eric Ladin
Detective Clarkin
Kerry O'Malley
Sharon Higgins
Brian Howe
Pete Higgins
Ivar Brogger
Dr. Burgher
Gabriel Bateman
Robert
Shiloh Nelson
Nancy
Morganna Bridgers
Debbie
Michelle Romano
Mary
Paige Diaz
Candy Striper
Tree O'Toole
Thin Woman; Annabelle
Trampas Thompson
Thin Man
Camden Singer
Clerk
Keira Daniels
Young Annabelle Higgins
Richard Allan Jones
Parishoner
Christopher Shaw
Fuller
Geoff Wehner
Neighbor
Sasha Sheldon
Nurse
Robin Pearson Rose
Mother
Joseph Bishara
Demonic Figure (uncredited)
Emily Brobst
Demonic Figure (uncredited)
Patrick Wilson
Ed Warren (archive footage) (uncredited)