Stephanie Sigman
Sister Charlotte
Talitha Bateman
Janice
Lulu Wilson
Linda
Anthony LaPaglia
Samuel Mullins
Miranda Otto
Esther Mullins
Grace Caroline Currey
Carol
Philippa Coulthard
Nancy
Samara Lee
Annabelle "Bee" Mullins
Tayler Buck
Kate
Lou Lou Safran
Tierney
Brad Greenquist
Victor Palmeri
Mark Bramhall
Father Massey
Joseph Bishara
Annabelle Demon
Alicia Vela-Bailey
Evil Mullins / Demon Hands
Jessie Giacomazzi
Demon Bee (voice)
Adam Bartley
Officer Form
Lotta Losten
Adoption agent
Brian Howe
Mr. Higgins
Kerry O'Malley
Mrs. Higgins
Annabelle Wallis
Mia Form
Ward Horton
John Form
Fred Tatasciore
Demon (voice)
Bonnie Aarons
Demon Nun (uncredited)
Liam James Ramos
Small Boy (uncredited)
Tyler A. Johnson
Priest Holding Annabelle (uncredited)
Tree O'Toole
Annabelle Higgins (uncredited)
Emily Brobst
Demon Nun (uncredited)