Sienna Miller
Deb Callahan
Christina Hendricks
Kath
Aaron Paul
Chris
Will Sasso
Terry
Sky Ferreira
Bridget Callahan
Pat Healy
Ray
Alex Neustaedter
Tyler Hanrick
E. Roger Mitchell
Det. Sergeant Morris
Kentucker Audley
Brett Tobeck
Aidan McGraw
Jesse (Age 7)
Aidan Fiske
Jesse (Age 13)
Amy Madigan
Peggy
Alexander Joseph Wildes
Jesse (Age 1)
Maximus Thomas Wildes
Jesse (Age 1)
Katie Elinoff
Cindy
Rene Cadet
Paul
Gavin Earle
Murph (Age 10)
Kobi Polisky
Patrick (Age 8)
Adrianne Krstansky
Carol Hanrick
Kelly Rose Golden
Jenna Cunningham
Bates Wilder
Detective O'Brien
Chet Harding
Local News Reporter
Gwen Callahan
Mrs. Clancy
Karen Elverson
Mrs. Caponi
Rosemary Mahoney
Mrs. Hastings
Maggie Castle
Brett's Wife
Dennis Staroselsky
Professor Walters
Tyler Wesley Parrish
Murph (Age 16)
Jack Brunault
Patrick (Age 14)
Maggie Budzyna
Colleen
Dottie Reid
Aunt Dottie
Jack Reid
Uncle Jack
Christopher Hickey
Priest
Rebecca Gibel
Nursing Assistant #1
Georgia Lyman
Nursing Assistant #2
Nancy Villone
Shawna
Matt Merritt
Murph (Age 21)
Logan Hallowell
Patrick (Age 18)
Sarah Amber Newcomb
Sarah
Dee Nelson
Mrs. Coates
Gillian Mariner Gordon
Derrick Daughter
Rachel Singer
Mrs. Derrick
Joseph Oliveira
Man at the House (uncredited)
Lexie Roth
Search Party Member (uncredited)
Danielle Lyons
Search Party Volunteer (uncredited)
Michael Marchand
Police Officer (uncredited)
Tom Mariano
Search Party Member (uncredited)
Mazen Elkot
Customer (uncredited)
Travis Starr
Football Fan (uncredited)
Lisa Wynn
Football Game Spectator (uncredited)