Surf & Turf round: Turf: Human Croquet--A large ball is hit with a noodle through wickets made out of teammates. The first team through the course twice wins. Before the game Art brings out Matthew Malach, identified as the head writer, and deems him ""responsible"" for the game. Red wins. Surf: Dolphin Walking Pool Toy Pickup--Player 1 pulls players 2 and 3 around the pool on inflatable dolphins. Those players must pick up pool toys with their mouths. 10 toys wins the game. All players immediately fall off the dolphins. Blue wins 9-8 despite the 10-toy rule. Scavenger Hunt: 1. Perform as circus act--Andy does some juggling. 2. Find the largest engagement ring--Blue finds one of 4 carats! 3. Organize and choreograph a dance troupe--Andy gets a halfway decent looking dance going. 4. Find a couple who met on a blind date--Red's couple reveals afterward that they didn't meet that way. 5. Make an edible Art Mann sculpture--Blue's doesn't look like much. Red finishes only two