After being chased by a man who runs a lasagna stand, Garfield finds a Cinderella book in the park and wishes for a fairy godmother to grant his wishes. Instead he gets a fairy godfather who grants him his wishes, but with a price. First he wishes for lasagna, so the godfather steals it from the stand, then Garfield wishes for money to buy lasagna, the godfather steals it from the bank and Garfield gets arrested. When Garfield is released he makes his 3rd wish worth his while....a fairy godmother. After she drags her no good husband back home, Garfield returns the book to the owner, and gets a tray of lasagna as a reward and gets his wish after all.