Rumours of love begin to fly when Tucker and Becca plan to go to another school dance together. Encouraged by Max, Becca squashes the rumours by avoiding Tucker. When he asks for her help, she volunteers Christine to teach baseball to his unenthusiastic little brother Horace. But Becca's strategy backfires and she becomes alarmed when she notices how much time Tucker and Christine are spending together. She fears she's lost her two best friends and jealousy makes her jump to ridiculous conclusions.